Today at 10 AM ET, The LiberalOasis Radio Show was broadcast on WHMP-AM in Western MA. My special guests were David Pakman, host of Midweek Politics and Lisa Baskin of the MidEast Peace Coalition of Western Massachusetts who offered their perspectives on the Israel-Palestine conflict.
During the interviews, I sought their reactions to three blog posts. "What Do American Jews Think About Gaza?" from Democracy Arsenal's Ilan Goldenberg, Brzezinski: Obama Must Press Agreement on Israelis and Palestinians by Huffington Post's Nathan Gardels and "Why I'm Not Blogging More About Gaza" by The Atlantic's Jeffrey Goldberg.
Video of the opening monologue, about prospects for President-Elect Barack Obama's American Recovery and Reinvestment Plan, is below. After that are related thoughts posted earlier at OurFuture.org, "Disorganized Dems? Or Democracy In Action?"
Disorganized Dems? Or Democracy In Action?
Such is the traditional media interpretation of the policy deliberations going on between the incoming Obama administration and members of Congress.
But read deeper into the stories and you don't find evidence of explosive hostility or deep conflict. There is civil debate and discussion, not "crossfire." There is desire to modify aspects of Obama's plan, but not its overarching thrust. Congress is still expected to pass legislation within a month of Obama's swearing-in, which is not exactly getting bogged down, but moving pretty swiftly.
This is the real media bias, a bias towards conflict, which leads towards sensationalism instead of clear-eyed analysis.
The slightest hint of policy disagreement allows the traditional media to revert into the comfortable narrative: Those Disorganized Dems!
And the heightened sense of conflict can make constructive criticism harder to convey and productive discussion difficult.
But hopefully what is actually going on is not Keystone Kop chaos, but healthy democracy in action.
Instead of one-party rule undermining checks and balances and stifling discussion, we may well be seeing how -- when a progressive mandate for action points everyone in the right direction -- a President, a Congress and their constituents can engage in calm debate to refine proposals while still acting in timely fashion.
Granted, it's never wise to assume a best-case scenario. I would urge you again to contact Congress and demand swift passage of the American Recovery and Reinvestment Plan to the keep pressure on for timely action. And I encourage anyone to express concern about any aspect of the plan one thinks could use improvement.
But know that the media is invested in assuming worst-case scenarios, because breathy conflict is more likely to grab attention than dispassionate analysis.
And don't let those headlines make us get caught up in phony narratives and lose focus on the substantive policy issues that really matter.