Liberal Oasis
HOME | SEARCH | ARCHIVES | INTERVIEWS | MANIFESTO | RSS FEED
GIVE TO THE: DNC DCCC DSCC MOVEON GELAC DFA ACT PM
DONATE TO THE OASIS | SHOP THE OASIS | CONTACT THE OASIS

GET TRUTH

Alternet

American Prospect

Black Commentator

Boston Review

Consortium News

Gadflyer

Grist

In These Times

Intervention

Mother Jones

Ms.

The Nation

The New Republic

The Progressive

Progressive Populist

Salon

Tom Paine

Utne

Washington Monthly

Women's eNews

Z

GET BLOGGED

Altercation

Bartcop

Body and Soul

Joe Conason

Daily Kos

Eschaton

MyDD

Nathan Newman

The Sideshow

Talk Left

Talking Points Memo

Tapped

Terminus

GET ACTIVE

ActNow!

The Email Activist

MoveOn

True Majority

GET COMMUNITY

Al Gore Democrats

Blog For America

Dem Party Meetup

Democratic Underground

Democrats.com

Institute for Global Communications

Music Row Democrats

Smirking Chimp

GET INSIDE THE SYSTEM

First Read

The Hill

The Note

Open Secrets

Political Wire

Politics1

Romenesko

GET CONGRESS BACK

From The Roots

The Stakeholder

GET LEGISLATION

Write your U.S. Rep

Write your Senator

Or call Congress
202-224-3121

GET WONKY

Applied Research Center

Center for American Progress

Center for Policy Alternatives

Commonweal Institute

Economic Policy Institute

Institute for Policy Studies

Institute for Women's Policy Research

Moving Ideas Network

NJ Policy Perspective

OMB Watch

GET A BUDGET

Center on Budget and Policy Priorities

Concord Coalition

National Priorities Project

GET RURAL

Center for Applied Rural Innovation

Center for Rural Affairs

Center for Rural Development

Center for Rural Strategies

Center for Rural Studies

GET MEDIA ANALYSIS

Daily Howler

FAIR

Lying Media Bastards

Media Matters for America

Media Study

Media Whores Online

Media Transparency

News Hounds

PR Watch

Take Back The Media

TV News Lies

We Want The Airwaves

GET POLLS

Democracy Corps

Electoral Vote Predictor

Polling Report

Prof. Pollkatz

Public Opinion Watch

GET MORE BLOGGED

BusyBusyBusy

Donkey Rising

Feministing

Mathew Gross

Kicking Ass

Ms. Musings

Notes on the Atrocities

onegoodmove

Pacific Views

Greg Palast

Road To Surfdom

Rittenhouse Review

Skippy

TBogg

GET LOCAL

SF Bay Guardian

Texas Observer

Village Voice

WHO NEEDS DRUDGE

The Agonist

BuzzFlash

Common Dreams

Cursor

Drudge Retort

Easter Lemming

Free Speech News

Intl-News

Make Them Accountable

Progressive Southerner

The Raw Story

The Screed

Seriously Though

Smudge Report

Truthout

Unknown News

USNewsLink

Working For Change

GET ECON BLOGGED

Angry Bear

Brad DeLong

MaxSpeak

GET BUSH

AWOL Bush

Babes Against Bush

Billionaires For Bush

Bush 2004

Bushwatch

Bush Draft

Bush Occupation

Bush Recall

Down With Bush

DubyaSpeak

Dumb and Dubya

GWBush04.com

Hated

Misleader

Peace Pretzel

ReDefeat Bush

StopBushin2004

Uproot Bush

Vote Bush Out

Whitehouse.org

GET JUDGES

Alliance For Justice

American Constitution Society

Independent Judiciary

GET FOREIGN POLICY

Arms Control Association

Brookings Institution

Carnegie Endowment

Carter Center

Center for Defense Information

Fourth Freedom Forum

Henry L. Stimson Center

9-11 Families for Peaceful Tomorrows

Peace Action

Traprock Peace Center

Veterans Against the Iraq War

Veterans For Common Sense

World Policy Institute

GET HOMELAND SECURITY

Century Foundation

GET IRAQ

Across The River

Back To Iraq 3.0

Baghdad Burning

Juan Cole

Iraq Body Count

Iraq Civilian War Casualties

Iraq Coalition Casualty Count

Raed In The Middle

GET FREEDOM

Amnesty International

Human Rights First

Human Rights Watch

GET GROUP BLOGGED

The American Street

Blogging of the President

Crooked Timber

Open Source Politics

GET LIFE WITHOUT PAROLE

Abolish The Death Penalty

Death Penalty Information Center

National Coalition to Abolish the Death Penalty

FIGHT CRIME

Fortune Society

National Center on Institutions & Alternatives

Sentencing Project

GET LEFT

Bear Left

Blog Left

Kick The Leftist

Lean Left

The Left Coaster

Left Is Right

Left Leaner

The Lefty Directory

MoveLeft Media

So Far, So Left

GET RIGHT

Con Web Watch

Evil GOP Bastards

GET META-BLOGGED

Best of the Blogs

Progressive Gold

GET GOOD GOVT

Center for Public Integrity

CitizenWorks

Common Cause

Public Citizen

GET ELECTION FRAUD

Black Box Voting

Verified Voting

GET STILL MORE BLOGGED

The Agora

Alas, A Blog

American Amnesia

Archpundit

Coherence Theory
of Truth

Corrente

Emphyrio

Green[e]house Effect

Hullabaloo

Just World News

Liquid List

Margaret Cho

Mike Hersh

Negrophile

Not Geniuses

Oliver Willis

Orcinus

Pandagon

Seeing The Forest

Trish Wilson

Warblogging

Whiskey Bar

GET GREEN

Climate Ark

The Detroit Project

Environmental Defense

Environmental Media Services

Natural Resources Defense Council

Sierra Club

What Would Jesus Drive?

GET UNION BLOGGED

Confined Space

Fight For The Future

Joe Hill Dispatch

Joe Kenehan

GET STATEHOOD

DC Vote

GET LAW BLOGGED

Balkinization

Discourse.net

Is That Legal?

Lessig Blog

GET GUN CONTROL

Brady Campaign to Prevent Gun Violence

Violence Policy Center

GET LOCAL BLOGS

Bay To The Beltway (SF)

Blog For Democracy (GA)

Blog St. Louis (MO)

BlueGrassRoots (KY)

Burnt Orange Report (TX)

Colorado Luis (CO)

Liberal Desert (AZ)

Off The Kuff (TX)

People's Republic
of Seabrook (TX)

Politics in the Zeros (CA)

A Progressive on the Prairie (SD)

Sooner Thought (OK)

South Knox
Bubba (TN)

To The Barricades (NE)

Twin Cities Babelogue (MN)

STOP SCREWING THE POOR

Class Struggle

JobWatch

Living Wage Resource Center

National Campaign for Jobs and Income Support

National Coalition Against Legalized Gambling

Welfare Information Network

GET GLOBALI-
ZATION

Capital Ownership Group

50 Years Is Enough

NetAid

Reclaim Democracy

GET RETIREMENT SECURITY

Alliance for Retired Americans

Nat'l Cmte to Preserve Social Security & Medicare

Social Security Network

GET HOLLYWOOD

The Creative Coalition

Scoobie Davis

GET IT ALL

eRiposte

The LiberalOasis Blog
The daily view from the oasis

HOLIDAY SCHEDULE: LO will post sporadically, as events warrant, from 12/24/04 to 1/2/05.

December 28, 2004 PERMALINK
Abortion Accommodation?
(posted Dec. 28 1:30 AM ET)

A political asessment by Adam Nagourney in the NY Times is not always something to be taken at face value.

So there’s no immediate need to go completely insane over last week’s piece, “Democrats Weigh De-emphasizing Abortion As An Issue”, which said:

Democratic leaders say their party needs to de-emphasize the issue of abortion rights, concerned that Republicans have hurt the Democratic Party by portraying it as an uncompromising champion of abortion.

In interviews and public appearances since Election Day, Democratic officials have said that the party should open its doors to abortion opponents and that candidates should make abortion a less central focus of future campaigns.

Party leaders said they were not abandoning their fundamental support for abortion rights, but said Democrats should consider accepting some restrictions that enjoy popular support - like parental notification when teenagers receive abortions.

An example of Nagourney’s sloppy reporting: he lumps in Howard Dean with accomodationist crowd:

Howard Dean, campaigning two weeks ago [for DNC Chair], drew nods of approval from Democratic state party leaders when he urged the party to embrace Democrats who oppose abortion.

"We ought not turn our back on pro-life people, even though the vast majority of people in this party are pro-choice," Dr. Dean said. "I don't have any objection to someone who is pro-life, if they really dedicated to the welfare of children."

But also two weeks ago, Dean said this on NBC’s Meet The Press:

We can change our vocabulary, but I don't think we ought to change our principles...

...We're not the party of abortion.  We're the party of allowing people to make up their own minds about medical treatment.

It's just a different way of phrasing it.  We have to start framing these issues, not letting them frame the issues.

You may not like his choice of frame (LiberalOasis is underwhelmed), but it’s sure not calling for de-emphasis of the issue, nor is it calling for “accepting some restrictions”.

Still, Nagourney didn’t make up the piece out of whole cloth. Clearly, some Beltway Dems are discussing how to capitulate on abortion.

It’s just the degree of the discussion that is left unclear by Nagourney’s untrustworthy reporting.

This discussion is typical of the accommodationist wing of the party, where any political setback can be solved by giving up on a key issue.

In 1992, it was welfare.

And in 1994, the GOP forced upon Clinton a harsher welfare reform than he bargained for, which he signed.

That proved to be politically smart for Clinton (it would have been perceived as breaking a campaign promise to veto it), but the policy hasn’t exactly stopped the rise in poverty in the last few years.

In 2000, gun control was blamed for Gore’s defeat in certain states, and so Dems largely shut up about it for the next four years.

And in 2004, we lost the ban on assault weapons, while Kerry was unable to pick up any Red states.

Now, for some Dems, it’s practically a competition to see how many issues we can surrender: gay rights, multilateralism, etc.

But why the gravitation to abortion as the capitulation du jour?

The party needs to “de-emphasize” the issue? What emphasis was there to speak of?

Did Kerry give one speech on the subject since the March For Women’s Lives back in April? Did the campaign run a single TV ad about abortion?

At least in 2000, Dems that wanted to duck gun control could point to the exit poll which said 48% of voters lived in gun-owning households. (By the way, that dropped to 41% in 2004.)

In 2004, what data is there that shows major weakening of support for abortion rights?

In 2000, 56% of voters said abortion should be always or mostly legal. In 2004, it was 55%, a statisically insignificant difference.

And the Bush-Kerry breakdown of “legal” voters and “illegal” voters was little changed from Bush-Gore (Bush does a little better with pro-choicers than the Dem does with pro-lifers).

That does show that the pro-choice majority is a bit softer than the pro-life minority.

And that’s been a tricky thing to fix, because with abortion being legal for so long, some pro-choicers are complacent. Debate fatigue is probably a factor too.

But if you believe that abortion should be legal, if you believe that abortion isn’t murder, if you believe that having the ability to choose if and when you have kids greatly improves the lives of women and children, then you’ll find a way to fight through that dynamic.

Because if you get cute, and think you’ll score political points by swearing you don’t like abortion either, you’ll further tilt the dynamic of the debate, and you’ll end up giving away more than you ever bargained for.

And there are a lot of Dems who will never forgive you for it.

The Blog Wire
Tracking the liberal blogosphere

MSNBC's Bloggermann: "the [OH] recount has been butchered, badly enough that even an editorial in Sunday's Toledo Blade noted 'the miserable performance of much of the American electoral system'"

MyDD (here and here) has the latest on the race for DNC chair

Roger Ailes watches Meet The Press this Sunday so LiberalOasis doesn't have to

Real Climate shreds George Will and Michael Crichton on climate change

Informed Comment: "The tsunami was caused by an earthquake and was unrelated to climate change. But everyone should realize that global warming contributes to extreme weather events"

Chris Mooney: Why It's Illegal to Teach Intelligent Design

Jesus' General busts a College Republican trying to gin up a fake "academic freedom" controversy, while The Nation looks at what liberals are doing to counter the Right's campus strategy

The Grey Matter: "Perhaps if the FDA was not so in bed with the pharma industry, this recent spate of recalls and pulled drugs could have been avoided"

**************

REVIEWS
What people are saying about LiberalOasis

"Among the best ways to [pay close attention to the grass roots] is logging onto Web sites like Liberal Oasis."
Joe Conason

"indispensable"
Tapped

"bloggeriffic"
Air America

"something interesting"
Eric Alterman

"quite well reasoned, almost scholarly"
Star Tribune's 2cents

"one of the sharpest political minds around"
Hartford Advocate

"must-read liberal mega-site"
Swing State Project

"unsurpassed political commentary"
P.L.A.

"wonderful"
BushOut.tv

"one of my many must-read-every-day sites"
Terminus

"it's what our site would be like [if we had] more time"
Bear Left

"smart new weblog for us lefties"
Reading & Writing

"always-excellent"
Groupthink Central

"consistently interesting"
Body and Soul

"If you're one of the few who has not been to Liberal Oasis, get on over there for great blogging, sharp humor and activism"
Ruminate This

"It's like a freakin' candy store!"
Chernovog's Journal

"Liberal Oasis is so good I ought to print it out and mail it to my Senators."
The Sideshow

"Excellent commentary"
The Guy James Show

July 26, 2002
"Political Site of the Day"
AboutPolitics.com

"Left-wing twits"
Right-thinking.com

"The parallel dimension in which supporters of Stalin, Hitler, Saddam Hussein and various and sundry other shitheels live."
The Anti-Idiotarian Rottweiler

"Pathetic site"
Sean Hannity

July 29, 2002
"The Many Faces of Satan© Website of the Week"
Patriotist.com

GET AIR AMERICA

Air America

Air America Links

Air America Place

Air America Talk

The Al Franken Show

The Majority Report

Morning Sedition

The Randi Rhodes Show

Unfiltered

GET HUMOR

The Boondocks

Will Durst

Mark Fiore

Get Your War On

La Cucaracha

Political Strikes

Ted Rall

This Modern World

Tom the Dancing Bug

GET A JOB

Idealist

Opportunity Knocks

GET ART

Ginger Young Gallery

GET MUSIC

Folkweb

Rapstation

WomanRock

GET FOOD

Eat Wild

EcoFriendly Foods

Get Vegan

Grassland Beef

Homestead Healthy Foods

Lasater Grasslands Beef

GET TRANS FATS

Ban Trans Fats

Boycott Hydrogenation

GET COFFEE

Coffee Traders

Counter Culture Coffee

Sacred Grounds

GET A DATE

Act For Love

Liberal Hearts

GET MORE HUMOR

Adult Christianity

Bean Magazine

Betty Bowers

Bloom County

Tom Burka

The Cougarstein Ramble

Fanatical Apathy

Faux News Channel

Foundation for a Patriotic America

Funny Times

Humor Gazette

I Drew This

Alexander Pierre Luboknovich

MadKane

Michael Moore

Nothing Like The Truth

Republican Press

Slowpoke Comics

The Specious Report

Tammy Faye Starlite

What Now Toons

GET BRITISH HUMOR

Lord Bonkers Diary

Private Eye

Viz

PLAY A GAME

Life as a Blackman

BUY STUFF...

Agitproperties

Axis of Eve

Brain Bump

EcoMall

Card Carrying Liberal

Global Exchange

Green Pages

Green People

Hybrid Car Dealers

Open Stickers

Real Goods

Responsible Shopper

...OR DON'T

AdBusters

Boycott Action News

Buy Nothing Day

GET OFF THE GRID

Back Home

Building Green

Home Power

Off-Grid Living

Solar Panels for Energy

Source for Renewable Energy

GET FUNDING

Ford Foundation

Pew Charitable Trusts

Soros Foundation

Tides Foundation

GET PR

Communication Works

Douglas Gould

Fenton Communications

Hauser Group

McKinney & Assoc.

The SPIN Project

Spitfire Strategies

GET CAPITAL GAINS

Calvert Foundation

Domini Social Investments

Greenmoney Journal

Parnassus Investments

GET UNIONIZED

AFL-CIO

SEIU

UAW

GET LAID SAFELY

Advocates for Youth

Nat'l Campaign to Prevent Teen Pregnancy

Planned Parenthood

Scarleteen

GET REPRO CHOICE

Center for Reproductive Law & Policy

NARAL Pro-Choice America

GET ABORTION

National Network of Abortion Funds

GET HAPPY ANIMALS

Alley Cat Allies

Animal Rescue Site

ASPCA

Best Friends

Stop Declaw

Wildlife Waystation

GET GOD

American Islamic Congress

The Ba'hai Faith

Buddhist Peace Fellowship

Catholic Worker

Center for Progressive Christianity

Center for the Study of Islam and Democracy

Clergy Leadership Network

Interfaith Alliance

Islamicate

Liberals Like Christ

Muslim WakeUp!

Noble Causes

Religious Action Center of Reform Judaism

The Religious Left

Shalom Center

Sojourners

Tikkun

Unitarian Universalists

United Church of Christ

Universal Life Church

Veiled 4 Allah

Velveteen Rabbi

The Village Gate

GET GODLESS

About Atheism

American Atheists

Church of Critical Thinking

Infidels

GET MOON

Where in Washington, D.C. is Sun Myung Moon?

Rick A. Ross Institute

GET EQUALITY

American-Arab Anti-Discrimination Committee

Anti-Defamation League

Human Rights Campaign

NAACP

Nat'l Conf. for Community and Justice

National Council of La Raza

National Urban League

NOW

GET MARRIED

Don't Amend

Freedom To Marry

HRC Marriage Center

Marriage Equality

Million For Marriage

GET UNMARRIED

Unmarried America

GET JUSTICE

ACLU

Brennan Center for Justice

EarthJustice

Lambda Legal Defense

Legal Momentum

Mexican American Legal Defense

NAACP Legal Defense

National Asian Pacific American Legal Consortium

Native American Rights Fund

Southern Poverty Law Center

GET RADIO

Air America

Arkansas Tonight

Bush Recession Radio

Democracy Now

Ed Schultz

Free Speech Radio

Free Speech Show

Guy James

Meria Heller

Mike Malloy

New Black City

Radio Free Exile

Radio Left

Radio Nation

Radio Power

Peter Werbe

Young Turks

GET AMERICAN

AMERICAblog

Americans for Democratic Action

Campaign for America's Future

Americans United for the Separation of Church and State

People For the American Way

GET SOMEONE ELECTED

America Coming Together

Democracy For America

Democratic National Committee

Emily's List

Gay & Lesbian Victory Fund

League of Independent Voters

MoveOn.org PAC

New Democrat Network

Progressive Majority

Punk Voter

21st Century Democrats

Wellstone Action

Young Democratic Candidates Network

GET SOME MORE BLOGS OVER HERE

Afro-Netizen

Ain'tNoBadDude

Alicublog

All Spin Zone

American Samizdat

Angry Finger

Angry Liberal

Annatopia

Apostropher

Aron's Israel Peace Blog

Arms and the Man

Auterrific

Ayn Clouter

Bad Attitudes

Beltway Bandit

Betsy Devine

Bolo Boffin

Cathie From Canada

Chris Mooney

CriticCorner

Daily Beast

Damfacrats

Damn Foreigner

David Sirota

Dean Nation

Decembrist

Dem Watch

Demagogue

Democratic Veteran

Electrolite

Empire Notes

Feministe

Freeway Blogger

Funny Farm

Gamers Nook

Head Heeb

Hellblazer

The Hamster

HugoZoom

Idols Of The Marketplace

Interesting Times

Isebrand

Into the Breach

Jusiper

Jesus' General

Just Another Bump In the Beltway

Mark A.R. Kleiman

Long Story; Short Pier

Mfinley

Mousemusings

Jack O'Toole

The Looking Glass

Mac-a-ro-nies

Making Light

Nattering Nabob

NDN Blog

An Old Soul

Orwellian Times

Pen-Elayne

Political Juice

The Poor Man

Progressive Spirit Blog

Project For a New Century of Freedom

Prometheus 6

Prometheus Speaks

Public Nuisance

Random Thoughts

Riba's Rambles

Roger Ailes

Rox Populi

Ruminate This

Sadly, No

Shadow of the Hegemon

Sharp Sand

Simon Templar

Sisyphus Shrugged

Slacktivist

Suburban Guerrilla

Suckful

Swing State Project

The Talent Show

The Talking Dog

Tom Dispatch

Tins

An Unenviable Situation

Uggabugga

Unmedia

Uppity Negro

Wampum

War Liberal

War and Piece

Matt Yglesias

HOME | SEARCH | ARCHIVES | MANIFESTO | SOAPBOX
DONATE TO THE OASIS | SHOP THE OASIS | CONTACT THE OASIS

Liberal Oasis Logo Design: Ed Kim | Advice and Assistance: LuckyDave, Gina-Louise Sciarra and Maya Voskoboynikov | Special Thanks to Eric Alterman, Bartcop, Hated.com, MediaWhoresOnline and Smirking Chimp for their early cybersupport